New York Strip with Easy Cowboy Butter Sauce

PlugNGrill Team

Servings

2

Prep Time

30 minutes

Category

Meat

Master the Bold "Cowboy Butter" Sizzle on the Turbo E Outdoor Electric Grill

The secret to a legendary New York Strip isn’t just the sear—it’s the soul-satisfying sauce that drips from every slice. Fire up your Turbo E Outdoor Electric Grill to lock in those juicy beef flavors, then let the star of the show take over: the Cowboy Butter Sauce. This isn't your average topping; it’s a molten gold blend of fresh garlic, zesty lemon, crushed red pepper, and fragrant herbs, all melted to perfection alongside your steak.

Even with a minimalist steak presentation, the Turbo E ensures your meat is the perfect canvas for this flavor explosion. As the bold, spicy, and buttery notes meld with the freshly grilled beef, you’ll realize that the right sauce doesn't just complement a meal—it defines it.

Craving something even more sophisticated and herb-forward? > If you're looking for a classic French touch, stay tuned. Our next recipe features the iconic Café de Paris Butter to satisfy your hunger for an even more complex, aromatic steakhouse experience!
New York Strip with Easy Cowboy Butter Sauce

Ingredients

  • 100g / 7 tbsp unsalted butter, softened, divided

  • 1 large garlic clove, finely minced (1 tsp) – knife best (Note 1) 

  • 1 tbsp Dijon mustard 

  • 1 tsp smoked paprika (sub regular paprika) 

  • 1 tsp chilli flakes / red pepper flakes 

  • 1/4 tsp cooking salt / kosher salt (halve for table salt)  

Directions

  1. Start by mixing all the ingredients into your butter

  2. If it’s a chilly day, you can microwave briefly

  3. After mixing, the butter can be used immediately or rolled in parchment paper into a log shape for convenient chilling and storage

  4. Next, grab your favorite steak - we’re using New York Strip

  5. Keep your steak simple, just olive oil, salt, and pepper

  6. We’re going for medium-rare, or medium if you prefer

  7. Let the grill’s resting heat melt that butter into a sauce

  8. Now you can either slice and dip

  9. Or just pour it all over the top

  10. Done! New York Strip with Easy Cowboy Butter ready, enjoy!
Back to blog